Hans in Luck | The Brothers Grimm

I like fairy tales, and a lot of good ones are not only in the public domain, but useful teaching aids as well. …although some of them teach a somewhat dark lesson… As a continuation of my “Secular Lessons” I’ll read some random fairy tales and copy-paste them on my blog. I’ll read them to my kid when he’s older.

Human speech is about 160 words per minute, and with that figure, I’ll post at the beginning of the stories how many minutes it might take to read it out loud to your kid. At the end of the story, I’ll post some questions I can think of (and maybe offer a few potential answers of my own), and if I happen to think of a fun activity to help further illustrate the story, I’ll also leave that as well.

Okay, here we go–the first fairy tale is from the Brothers Grimm, “Hans in Luck”

Hans in Luck

Length: 1800 words; 11.5 minutes.

Hans had served his master seven years, and at last said to him, ‘Master, my time is up, I should like to go home and see my mother; so give me my wages.’

And the master said, ‘You have been a faithful and good servant, so your pay shall be handsome.’ Then he gave him a piece of silver that was as big as his head.

Hans Sets Out

Hans took out his pocket-handkerchief, put the piece of silver into, it, threw it over his shoulder, and jogged off homewards. As he went lazily on, dragging one foot after another, a man came in sight, trotting along gaily on a capital horse.

‘Ah!’ said Hans aloud, ‘What a fine thing it is to ride on horseback! There he sits as if he was at home in his chair; he trips against no stones, spares his shoes, and yet gets on he hardly knows how.’

The horseman heard this, and said, ‘Well, Hans, why do you go on foot then!’

‘Ah!’ said he, ‘I have this load to carry; to be sure it is silver, but it is so heavy that I can’t hold up my head, and it hurts my shoulder sadly.’

‘What do you say to changing?’ said the horseman; ‘I will give you my horse, and you shall give me the silver.’

‘With all my heart,’ said Hans; ‘but I tell you one thing, — you’ll have a weary task to drag it along.’

The horseman got off, took the silver, helped Hans up, gave him the bridle into his hand, and said, ‘When you want to go very fast, you must smack your lips loud, and cry “Jip”.’

Hans was delighted as he sat on the horse, and rode merrily on. After a time he thought he should like to go a little faster, so he smacked his lips, and cried ‘Jip’. Away went the horse full gallop; and before Hans knew what he was about, he was thrown off, and lay in a ditch by the roadside; and his horse would have run off, if a shepherd who was coming by, driving a cow, had not stopped it.

Hans Buys a Cow

Hans soon came to himself, and got upon his legs again. He was sadly vexed, and said to the shepherd, ‘This riding is no joke when a man gets on a beast like this, that stumbles and flings him off as if he would break his neck. However, I’m off now once for all: I like your cow a great deal better! One can walk along at one’s leisure behind her, and have milk, butter, and cheese every day into the bargain. What would I give to have such a cow!’

‘Well,’ said the shepherd, ‘if you are so fond of her, I will change my cow for your horse.’

‘Done!’ said Hans merrily. The shepherd jumped upon the horse and away he rode.

Hans drove off his cow quietly, and thought his bargain a very lucky one. ‘If I have only a piece of bread (and I certainly shall be able to get that), I can, whenever I like, eat my butter and cheese with it; and when I am thirsty I can milk my cow and drink the milk. What can I wish for more?’ Then he came to an inn, he halted, ate up all his bread, and gave away his last penny for a glass of beer. Then he drove his cow towards his mother’s village; and the heat grew greater as noon came on, till at last he found himself on a wide heath that would take him more than an hour to cross, and he began to be so hot and parched that his tongue clave to the roof of his mouth. ‘I can find a cure for this,’ thought he; ‘now will I milk my cow and quench my thirst’; he tied her to the stump of a tree, and held his leathern cap to milk into; but not a drop was to be had.

Hans Buys a Pig

While he was trying his luck and managing the matter very clumsily, the uneasy beast gave him a kick on the head that knocked him down, and there he lay a long while senseless. Luckily a butcher soon came by driving a pig in a wheelbarrow. ‘What is the matter with you?’ said the butcher as he helped him up. Hans told him what had happened, and the butcher gave him a flask, saying. ‘There, drink and refresh yourself; your cow will give you no milk, she is an old beast good for nothing but the slaughterhouse.’

‘Alas, alas!’ said Hans, ‘who would have thought it? If I kill her, what will she be good for? I hate cow-beef, it is not tender enough for me. If it were a pig now, one could do something with it; it would at any rate make some sausages.’

‘Well,’ said the butcher, ‘to please you I’ll change, and give you the pig for the cow.’

‘Heaven reward you for your kindness!’ said Hans as he gave the butcher the cow, and took the pig off the wheelbarrow, and drove it off, holding it by the string that was tied to its leg.

Hans Buys a Goose

So on he jogged, and all seemed now to go right with him; he had met with some misfortunes, to be sure; but he was now well repaid for all. The next person he met was a countryman carrying a fine white goose under his arm. The countryman stopped to ask what was o’clock; and Hans told all his luck, and how he had made so many good bargains. The countryman said he was going to take the goose to a christening; ‘Feel,’ said he, ‘how heavy it is, and yet it is only eight weeks old. Whoever roasts and eats it may cut plenty of fat off it, it has lived so well!’

‘You’re right,’ said Hans as he weighed it in his hand; ‘but my pig is no trifle.’

Meantime the countryman began to look grave, and shook his head. ‘Hark ye,’ said he, ‘my good friend; your pig may get you into a scrape; in the village I just came from, the squire has had a pig stolen out of his sty. I was dreadfully afraid, when I saw you, that you had got the squire’s pig; it will be a bad job if they catch you; the least they’ll do will be to throw you into the horsepond.’

Poor Hans was sadly frightened. ‘Good man,’ cried he, ‘pray get me out of this scrape; you know this country better than I, take my pig and give me the goose.’

‘I ought to have something into the bargain,’ said the countryman; ‘however, I will not bear hard upon you, as you are in trouble.’ Then he took the string in his hand, and drove off the pig by a side path; while Hans went on the way homeward free from care. ‘After all,’ thought he, ‘I have the best of the bargain: first there will be a capital roast, then the fat will find me in goose-grease for six months; and then there are all the beautiful white feathers; I will put them into my pillow, and then I am sure I shall sleep soundly without rocking. How happy my mother will be!’

Hans Buys a Stone

As he came to the last village, he saw a scissor-grinder, with his wheel, working away, and singing:

‘O’er hill and o’er dale so happy I roam,
Work light and live well, all the world is my home;
Who so blythe, so merry as I?’

Hans stood looking for a while, and at last said, ‘you must be well off, master grinder, you seem so happy at your work.’

‘Yes,’ said the other, ‘mine is a golden trade; a good grinder never puts his hand in his pocket without finding money in it: — but where did you get that beautiful goose?’

‘I did not buy it, but changed a pig for it.’

‘And where did you get the pig?’

‘I gave a cow for it.’

‘And the cow?’

‘I gave a horse for it.’

‘And the horse?’

‘I gave a piece of silver as big as my head for that.’

‘And the silver?’

‘Oh! I worked hard for that seven long years.’

‘You have thriven well in the world hitherto,’ said the grinder; ‘now if you could find money in your pocket whenever you put your hand into it, your fortune would be made.’

‘Very true: but how is that to be managed?’

‘You must turn grinder like me,’ said the other; ‘you only want a grindstone; the rest will come of itself. Here is one that is a little the worse for wear: I would not ask more than the value of your goose for it; — win you buy?’

‘How can you ask such a question?’ replied Hans; ‘I should be the happiest man in the world if I could have money whenever I put my hand in my pocket; what could I want more? There’s the goose!’

‘Now,’ said the grinder, as he gave him a common rough stone that lay at his side, ‘this is a most capital Stone; do but manage it cleverly, and you can make an old nail cut with it.’

Hans took the stone and went off with a light heart: his eyes sparkled for joy, and he said to himself, ‘I must have been born in a lucky hour; everything that I want or wish for comes to me of itself.’

Hans Takes a Break From his Travels

Meantime he began to be tired, for he had been travelling ever since daybreak; he was hungry, too, for he had given away his last penny in his joy at getting the cow. At last he could go no farther, and the stone tired him terribly; he dragged himself to the side of a pond, that he might drink some water, and rest awhile; so he laid the stone carefully by his side on the bank; but as he stooped down to drink, he forgot it, pushed it a little, and down it went plump into the pond. For a while he watched it sinking in the deep clear water, then sprang up for joy, and again fell upon his knees, and thanked heaven with tears in his eyes for its kindness in taking away his only plague, the ugly heavy stone. ‘How happy am I!’ cried he: ‘no mortal was ever so lucky as I am.’ Then up he got with a light and merry heart, and walked on free from all his troubles, till he reached his mother’s house.


  1. What’s the moral of the story? Learning to spend your money wisely? Be skeptical of people trying to sell you something? Consider your purchases carefully before buying?
  2. Was Hans treated fairly?
  3. Do you think it’s a good thing that Hans had such a positive outlook at the end despite having lost everything?
  4. Discuss the value of hard work.
  5. Discuss the role of jealousy in this story.
  6. [Your question here, leave a comment!]


  1. Sit down with your kid and teach them about counting money, making change, etc.
  2. Play a board game with play money like Monopoly or Payday.
  3. Coach them through the process of making a bigger purchase.
  4. Field trip: Go to the grocery store with a budget. Have your child choose items and purchase them.
  5. Food: the story mentions a delicious roasted goose. Celebrate having read this story with a roasted goose or chicken! I linked a recipe, but this is a very simple thing to make so have your child help out.
  6. [Your activity here, leave a comment!]

Because this is my first official post on a secular lesson plan, I’m also going to re-post a list from a previous article. This is mostly for my benefit as I develop these lessons, to remind me of various facets of each one. I’ll be using this article as a template for those to come.

  • read a story/assign a book
  • find pictures and coloring pages
  • watch a movie
  • listen to a podcast
  • listen to a song
  • activity/field trip
  • Make themed food
  • hands on/craft
  • play a game (check app store as well)

For more stories like this, check out my source on Archive.org

Image credit: Ben Gillin

Leave Your Thoughts

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.